“The Thing That Should Not Be” Blends Crushing Doom With Unsettling Atmosphere

Emerging from the depths of early 1990s death metal, “The Thing That Should Not Be” by Metallica is a chilling testament to the band’s willingness to explore darker sonic landscapes. This iconic track isn’t just heavy; it’s an atmospheric journey into existential dread, weaving intricate guitar melodies with brutal drumming and James Hetfield’s haunting vocal delivery. Released on their 1986 album “Master of Puppets,” the song became a fan favorite, solidifying Metallica’s position as pioneers of thrash metal while showcasing their evolving musical depth.
A Descent into Madness:
The song opens with a slow, ominous guitar riff that sets an immediately unsettling tone. Kirk Hammett’s haunting lead melody weaves its way through the dense rhythm section created by Lars Ulrich’s thunderous drumming and James Hetfield and Jason Newsted’s heavy, chugging riffs. The lyrics, inspired by H.P. Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos, depict a chilling narrative of an ancient, monstrous entity that lurks beneath the surface of reality, waiting to unleash unspeakable horrors upon humanity.
Hetfield’s vocals perfectly capture the song’s sense of dread and impending doom. He shifts effortlessly between guttural growls and mournful cries, conveying the terror and helplessness of those who encounter “The Thing That Should Not Be.” The song builds in intensity as it progresses, culminating in a frenetic climax that leaves the listener breathless.
Musical Anatomy:
“The Thing That Should Not Be” is a masterclass in musical composition and arrangement. Metallica’s use of dynamics creates a sense of tension and release throughout the song, keeping the listener on the edge of their seat. The interplay between Hammett’s soaring lead guitar melodies and Hetfield’s heavy rhythm riffs creates a sonic landscape that is both beautiful and terrifying.
Here’s a breakdown of some key musical elements:
Element | Description |
---|---|
Tempo | Varied, ranging from slow and ominous to fast and frantic. |
Key | E minor, creating a dark and brooding atmosphere. |
Guitar Riffs | Heavy and chugging, with intricate lead melodies that add depth and texture. |
Drumming | Powerful and dynamic, driving the song forward. |
Vocals | Harsh growls and mournful cries, conveying a sense of fear and despair. |
Metallica’s Evolution:
“The Thing That Should Not Be” marked a significant shift in Metallica’s sound. While their earlier albums showcased raw aggression and speed, this track revealed a newfound maturity and complexity. The band’s willingness to experiment with different musical styles and tempos solidified their status as one of the most innovative metal bands of all time.
The song also foreshadowed Metallica’s future explorations into darker lyrical themes. Their subsequent albums would delve deeper into topics such as war, death, addiction, and mental illness, further cementing their place as thought-provoking and culturally influential musicians.
Legacy and Impact:
“The Thing That Should Not Be” continues to resonate with metal fans decades after its release. The song’s haunting melodies, powerful lyrics, and masterful musicianship have inspired countless other bands and continue to be a staple of Metallica’s live performances. Its enduring popularity is a testament to the band’s ability to craft music that is both technically impressive and emotionally engaging.
The influence of “The Thing That Should Not Be” can be heard in the music of numerous metal bands, from death metal giants like Cannibal Corpse and Morbid Angel to progressive metal acts such as Dream Theater and Opeth. The song’s exploration of dark themes and atmospheric sound design paved the way for a new generation of heavy metal musicians who would continue to push the boundaries of the genre.
More than Just Heavy Metal:
“The Thing That Should Not Be” is more than just a brutal, headbanging anthem. It’s a chilling exploration of fear, despair, and the dark side of human nature. The song’s unsettling atmosphere and haunting melodies have captivated listeners for generations, cementing its place as one of Metallica’s most iconic and enduring tracks.